Skip to main content

Why can't conservatives see the benefits of affordable child care?

Printer-friendly version
Author: 
Livingston, Jay
Publication Date: 
13 Aug 2014

 

EXCERPTS

Ross Douthat is puzzled. He seems to sense that a liberal policy might actually help, but his high conservative principles and morality keep him from taking that step. It's a political version of Freudian repression - the conservative superego forcing tempting ideas to remain out of awareness.

In his column, Douthat recounts several anecdotes of criminal charges brought against parents whose children were unsupervised for short periods of time. The best-known of these criminals of late is Debra Harrell, the mother in South Carolina who let her 9-year-old daughter go to a nearby playground while she (Debra) worked at her job at McDonald's. The details of the case make it clear that this was not a bad mom - not cruel, not negligent. The playground was the best child care she could afford.

One solution should be obvious - affordable child care. But the U.S. is rather stingy when it comes to kids. Other countries are way ahead of us on public spending for children.

Conservatives will argue that child care should be private not public and that local charities and churches do a better job than do state-run programs. Maybe so. The trouble is that those private programs are not accessible to everyone. If Debra Harrell had been in France or Denmark, the problem would never have arisen.

The other conservative U.S. policy that put Debra Harrell in the arms of the law is "welfare reform." As Douthat explains, in the U.S., thanks to changes in the welfare system much lauded by conservatives, the U.S. now has "a welfare system whose work requirements can put a single mother behind a fast-food counter while her kid is out of school."

That's the part that perplexes Douthat. He thinks that it's a good thing for the government to force poor women to work, but it's a bad thing for those women not to have the time to be good mothers. The two obvious solutions - affordable day care or support for women who stay home to take care of kids - conflict with the cherished conservative ideas: government bad, work good.

...

read online at The Society Pages

article
Entered Date: 
27 Aug 2014
Premium Drupal Themes by Adaptivethemes
randomness